NHL Rumors: Maple Leafs Discussed Matthew Knies Trade, But Deal Was Never Close

Discussions regarding Toronto Maple Leafs forward Matthew Knies were a significant topic among trade rumors leading up to the deadline, with speculation notably involving the Montreal Canadiens.

Chris Johnston on Matthew Knies Trade Speculation

According to hockey insider Chris Johnston, the Toronto Maple Leafs undeniably engaged in discussions concerning Matthew Knies. However, Johnston believes the extent to which a deal neared completion has likely been exaggerated in some circles. He clarified that he doesn't have the impression that negotiations reached their final stages or that the Leafs narrowly missed a trade involving Knies.

Johnston highlighted the strategic reasons for the Leafs to listen to offers for Knies. Lacking protection in his contract, Knies represents arguably the most valuable asset the Leafs possess in terms of trade flexibility, especially when compared to players with no-movement clauses who dictate their destinations. Given the team's season trajectory, it was logical for the Leafs to assess Knies' market value. Johnston reiterated his belief that a deal was not particularly close but acknowledged that all options were effectively on the table. The insights gained could influence future decisions, potentially revisiting the topic in the summer.

Darren Dreger on Market Inquiries and Valuation

Darren Dreger added that while every team has players who are nearly "untouchable," general managers routinely make exploratory calls, posing "what if" scenarios. This was precisely the case with the Montreal Canadiens regarding Knies. Dreger suggested that if Montreal had presented a substantial package—hypothetically including a player like Michael Hage and two first-round draft picks—the Maple Leafs would have been open to a serious conversation. However, such an enticing offer was never made, and thus, negotiations did not advance to that stage.

Dreger confirmed that other teams, albeit a small number, also inquired about Knies. He drew a parallel to the Leafs' own inquiries about players like Robert Thomas of the St. Louis Blues, noting that any potential return for such a player would likely involve Knies plus additional assets. Crucially, Dreger emphasized that the Maple Leafs were never actively "shopping" Matthew Knies. Instead, the situation revolved around general managers initiating calls to inquire about what it would take for Toronto to consider trading him—a significant distinction from actively putting a player on the trade block.